The Only 10 Things That Matter in a GBP Audit in 2025

By Leela

I'll never forget the moment I realized I'd been doing Google Business Profile audits completely wrong.

It was 2 a.m., and I was staring at a spreadsheet with 47 different audit checkpoints for a client's restaurant chain. I'd spent hours checking every single field, every possible setting, every tiny detail Google offered. The client called the next day: "This is great, but... what do I actually do with all this?"

That's when it hit me. I'd been so focused on checking every box that I'd buried the stuff that actually moves the needle under a mountain of nice-to-haves.

Here's the thing about GBP audits in 2025—they're not about perfection. They're about priorities. After auditing hundreds of profiles and watching what actually drives results, I've learned that most businesses waste time on details that don't matter while ignoring the 10 things that make all the difference.

This guide cuts through the noise. I'm going to walk you through the exact 10 elements I check first in every audit, why they matter more than everything else, and how to fix them fast. By the end, you'll know exactly where to focus your energy to actually improve your local search visibility—not just create a prettier checklist.

So, What Exactly Are the Only 10 Things That Matter in a GBP Audit in 2025?

A GBP audit in 2025 isn't about checking every possible field—it's about focusing on the 10 core elements that directly impact your local search rankings and customer actions. These are your NAP consistency, business categories, description optimization, visual content quality, services/products listing, attributes, review management, local schema markup, performance analytics, and profile completeness. Everything else? Nice-to-have at best.

Think of it like a health checkup. Your doctor doesn't run every test in the book—they focus on vital signs first. Same principle here.

Let me break down what actually matters and why.

Why This Matters More Than Ever in 2025

Local search has gotten brutally competitive. I'm talking really competitive.

According to recent data, over 50% of consumers use Google Business Profile to find local businesses every single month. That's half your potential customers starting their journey right there. But here's where it gets interesting—businesses with complete GBP profiles are 2.7 times more likely to be considered reputable by customers.

That's not a small edge. That's the difference between getting the call and watching it go to your competitor down the street.

I learned this the hard way with a salon client last year. They had a GBP profile—technically. But their hours were outdated (from pre-pandemic), they hadn't responded to a review in eight months, and their photos were... let's just say they weren't doing anyone any favors. They were frustrated because they "had a Google listing" but weren't getting calls.

After focusing on just these 10 core elements—no fancy tricks, no expensive tools, just getting these fundamentals right—they saw a 42% increase in direction requests and a 28% jump in website clicks within 90 days.

The businesses winning local search in 2025 aren't doing more. They're doing the right things consistently.

The 10 Non-Negotiables: Your Real Audit Checklist

1. NAP Consistency (Name, Address, Phone Number)

This is the foundation. Everything else you do builds on this.

Your NAP needs to be identical—and I mean identical—across your GBP, website, and every other online listing. Not similar. Not close enough. Identical.

I once worked with a dental practice that couldn't figure out why they weren't ranking. Turns out they had "Dr. Smith's Dental Care" on their website, "Smith Dental Care" on GBP, and "Smith's Family Dentistry" on a directory listing. Google looked at all three and basically threw up its hands.

What to check:

  • Business name matches exactly across all platforms (no added keywords)
  • Address formatting is consistent, including suite numbers
  • Phone number is the same everywhere (not different tracking numbers on different platforms)
  • Hours are current and match reality
  • Website URL is correct and working

Red flag: If you moved locations or changed phone numbers in the past year and haven't updated everywhere, fix this first. Like, right now. Before you read the rest of this article.

The impact? Businesses with consistent NAP information see significantly better local rankings because Google trusts the data. Inconsistency makes Google wonder if you're even the same business.

2. Primary and Secondary Business Categories

Categories are how Google understands what you do. Get them wrong, and you're invisible for the searches that matter.

Your primary category should be the most specific match for your main business activity. Not what sounds good. Not what gets more searches. What you actually are.

I made this mistake early on with a coffee shop client. They also sold pastries and sandwiches, so I set their primary category to "Restaurant." Made sense, right? Wrong. Their traffic tanked. Once we switched to "Coffee Shop" as primary and added "Bakery" and "Sandwich Shop" as secondary categories, they started showing up again.

What to check:

  • Primary category is the most accurate representation of your core business
  • You're using all available secondary category slots (up to 5)
  • Categories come from Google's official list—no making stuff up
  • You haven't chosen overly broad categories when specific ones exist

Research shows businesses with 4 or more relevant categories rank 15-20% higher in local search results. That's huge.

Pro tip: Don't try to game the system by choosing high-volume categories that don't fit. Google's gotten really good at spotting this, and it'll hurt you more than help.

3. Business Description That Actually Sells

Your description has one job: tell people why they should choose you in 750 characters or less.

Most descriptions I audit are either keyword-stuffed nightmares or so generic they could describe any business in that category. Neither works.

Here's what I've learned works: Write like you're explaining your business to a friend who just asked "So what do you do?"

What to check:

  • Opens with what makes you different, not "Welcome to our business"
  • Includes relevant keywords naturally (your services, location, specialty)
  • Mentions specific benefits customers get
  • Written in clear, simple language
  • No keyword stuffing or awkward phrasing
  • Actually sounds like a human wrote it

Bad example: "We are a leading provider of automotive repair services offering comprehensive solutions for all vehicle maintenance needs with experienced technicians delivering quality service."

Better example: "Family-owned auto repair shop serving downtown Portland since 2015. We specialize in hybrid vehicles and offer same-day service for most repairs. Our ASE-certified mechanics explain everything in plain English—no surprises, no upselling."

See the difference? The second one tells you who they are, what they're good at, and why you might want to call them.

4. Fresh, High-Quality Visual Content

Photos and videos aren't decoration. They're conversion tools.

Profiles with photos receive 42% more requests for directions and 35% more clicks to websites, according to Google's own data. But here's what most businesses miss—it's not just about having photos. It's about having current photos that actually represent your business.

I audited a restaurant last month that had beautiful photos... from 2019. They'd completely renovated in 2022. Every customer walking in experienced a disconnect between what they expected and what they got.

What to check:

  • At least one photo uploaded in the last 90 days
  • Exterior shot showing your storefront/entrance
  • Interior shots that represent the current space
  • Photos of your actual products or services
  • Team photos if relevant
  • Minimum 10-15 high-quality images total
  • Videos if you have them (even short ones perform well)

Quality matters: Blurry phone photos from 2018 aren't cutting it anymore. You don't need professional photography, but you need clear, well-lit images taken on a modern smartphone at minimum.

Quick win: Take new photos every season. It signals to Google (and customers) that your business is active and current.

5. Complete Services and Products Listing

This section is criminally underused. It's basically free real estate to tell Google exactly what you offer, and most businesses leave it blank or half-done.

When you list services or products, you're giving Google more ways to match you to relevant searches. Someone searching for "brake repair near me" is more likely to find you if "Brake Repair" is listed in your services with a description and price range.

What to check:

  • All major services/products are listed
  • Each has a clear, benefit-focused description
  • Prices or price ranges included where possible
  • Keywords naturally incorporated (think about what customers search for)
  • Descriptions are scannable and easy to read

I worked with an HVAC company that was only listing "HVAC Services." When we broke it out into specific services—"Emergency Furnace Repair," "AC Installation," "Duct Cleaning," "Thermostat Replacement"—each with descriptions and price ranges, their visibility for long-tail searches shot up.

Don't overthink it: You don't need to list every single thing you've ever done. Focus on your main offerings and what people actually search for.

6. Attributes That Match Your Business

Attributes are those little tags like "wheelchair accessible" or "women-led" that help customers filter search results.

They seem minor until you realize someone just filtered their search to only show businesses with the attribute you didn't select.

What to check:

  • All applicable attributes are selected
  • Accessibility features are accurately represented
  • Service options (online appointments, delivery, etc.) are current
  • Special designations (LGBTQ+ friendly, veteran-owned, etc.) are claimed if applicable
  • You've reviewed attributes recently—Google adds new ones regularly

Here's something interesting I've noticed: Businesses that actively manage attributes tend to get more engagement. My theory? It signals you're paying attention to your profile, which correlates with better overall profile quality.

Reality check: Only select attributes that are genuinely true. Claiming "wheelchair accessible" when you have three steps to the entrance isn't just bad SEO—it's bad ethics and potentially illegal.

7. Review Management That Actually Happens

Reviews aren't a "set it and forget it" thing. They're an ongoing conversation that directly impacts your rankings and conversions.

Responding to reviews can increase customer engagement by up to 25%, according to BrightLocal's research. But most businesses I audit either ignore reviews entirely or only respond to the bad ones (which looks... not great).

What to check:

  • Response rate to reviews (aim for 100% or close to it)
  • Average response time (faster is better)
  • Response quality (personalized, not templated)
  • How negative reviews are handled
  • Whether you're encouraging reviews from happy customers
  • Q&A section is monitored and answered

I'll be honest—this is where most businesses fall down. Not because they don't care, but because they don't have a system.

What works: Set up notifications so you know immediately when a review comes in. Respond within 24-48 hours. Thank positive reviewers specifically for what they mentioned. For negative reviews, acknowledge the issue, apologize if appropriate, and offer to make it right offline.

One of my clients turned a brutal 1-star review into a 5-star update just by responding quickly and professionally. The customer edited their review to say "I'm changing my rating because of how they handled my complaint."

That's powerful.

8. Local Schema Markup on Your Website

Okay, this one's a bit more technical, but stay with me.

Local schema markup is code you add to your website that helps search engines understand your business details. It's like giving Google a cheat sheet: "Here's my name, address, phone, hours, and here's proof it matches my GBP."

This is the piece most small businesses skip because it sounds complicated. And honestly? It's the one that often requires a developer or technical help. But it matters.

What to check:

  • LocalBusiness schema is present on your website
  • NAP information in the schema matches GBP exactly
  • Hours are included and current
  • Schema includes your GBP URL if possible
  • No errors when tested with Google's Rich Results Test

If you're not technical, you can use schema plugins (for WordPress) or hire someone on Upwork for a few hours to set this up. It's a one-time thing that keeps working for you.

Why it matters: Schema markup helps Google connect your website to your GBP and verify your information is consistent. It's part of the trust signals Google looks for.

9. Performance Analytics You Actually Monitor

You can't improve what you don't measure. Cliché? Sure. True? Absolutely.

Your GBP Performance tab shows you exactly how customers are finding and interacting with your profile. Most businesses never look at it.

What to check:

  • How customers search for you (direct vs. discovery searches)
  • What queries bring up your profile
  • How many calls, website clicks, direction requests you're getting
  • How your numbers trend over time
  • Where your photos are being viewed

I use this data to figure out what's working. If I see a spike in calls after adding certain photos or updating the description, I know what resonated. If direction requests are down, maybe the address isn't displaying clearly.

Tools that help: The built-in dashboard is fine for basics, but tools like GMBMantra can automate tracking and give you insights without manual data export every week.

Real talk: If you're not checking your performance at least monthly, you're flying blind. Set a calendar reminder. Make it a habit.

10. Profile Completeness (Yes, All of It)

This sounds obvious, but you'd be shocked how many profiles I audit that are 60-70% complete.

Every empty field is a missed opportunity to give Google more information and customers more reasons to choose you.

What to check:

  • Every available field is filled out
  • No spelling or grammar errors anywhere
  • Opening date is set (if you have one)
  • Payment methods are listed
  • Service area is defined (for service-area businesses)
  • Appointment links work
  • Menu (for restaurants) is current
  • Nothing is marked temporarily closed if you're open

Google's own research shows complete profiles are significantly more likely to be viewed as reputable. Completeness signals you care about your business presence.

The 80/20 rule doesn't apply here: You need to complete 100% of applicable fields, not just the main ones. It takes an extra 30 minutes once, and then you're just maintaining it.

How Does This Actually Work in Practice?

Let me walk you through what a real audit looks like using these 10 elements.

When I start an audit, I don't open a 47-point checklist. I open the GBP profile and methodically check these 10 things in order.

Step 1: NAP verification (5 minutes) I pull up the GBP, the business website, and do a quick search for their name + city to see what other listings exist. I'm looking for discrepancies. If I find any, that's the first fix.

Step 2: Category check (3 minutes) I look at their primary category and ask: "Is this the most specific category that describes what they do?" Then I check if they're using all 5 secondary category slots with relevant options.

Step 3: Description review (5 minutes) I read their description like a potential customer. Does it tell me what makes them different? Does it have keywords that match what people search for? Is it readable?

Step 4: Visual content audit (10 minutes) I scroll through all photos. When was the last upload? Are they high quality? Do they show the current business? Are there glaring gaps (like no exterior shot)?

Step 5: Services/products review (10 minutes) Are they using this section? Is it complete? Are descriptions helpful or just keyword lists?

Step 6: Attributes check (3 minutes) Quick scan of all available attributes. Are obvious ones missing? Are claimed attributes accurate?

Step 7: Review response audit (15 minutes) I look at their last 20 reviews. How many have responses? How quickly? What's the quality of responses? How are negative reviews handled?

Step 8: Schema verification (5 minutes) I check their website source code or use Google's Rich Results Test to see if schema exists and matches GBP data.

Step 9: Performance data review (10 minutes) I look at their insights for the last 3 months. What's trending up or down? What search queries are bringing people to their profile?

Step 10: Completeness scan (5 minutes) I go through every section and field to spot anything incomplete or outdated.

Total time: About 70 minutes for a thorough audit of a single location.

Compare that to the 3+ hours I used to spend checking everything under the sun. This approach is faster and more effective because I'm focused on what matters.

What Are the Main Benefits and Drawbacks?

Benefits of Focusing on These 10 Elements

Efficiency: You're not wasting time on details that don't move the needle. I've seen businesses obsess over the perfect business hours format while ignoring that they haven't responded to a review in six months.

Measurable impact: Every one of these 10 elements directly affects either your rankings or conversion rate. You can track improvement.

Manageable maintenance: Once these 10 things are dialed in, maintaining them takes maybe an hour a month. That's sustainable for any business.

Competitive advantage: Most of your competitors aren't even doing these basics well. Getting them right puts you ahead.

I worked with a home services company that had been struggling with local visibility. They'd tried paid ads, social media campaigns, the works. When we focused just on these 10 GBP elements—nothing fancy, just getting the fundamentals right—they increased their local search visibility by 40% in three months. No ad spend required.

Drawbacks and Limitations

It's not magic: Fixing these 10 things won't transform a brand-new business with zero reviews into the #1 result overnight. This is about building a solid foundation.

Some elements need ongoing attention: Review management and content freshness aren't one-and-done. They require consistent effort.

Technical barrier: Schema markup might require help if you're not technically inclined. That's an investment of time or money.

Competition matters: If you're in a hyper-competitive market, these 10 elements are necessary but might not be sufficient. You might need additional strategies.

Google changes things: Google regularly updates GBP features. What's available today might change tomorrow, so you need to stay somewhat current.

Here's my honest take: This approach won't solve every local search challenge. But it will solve most of them for most businesses. And it's way better than doing nothing or trying to do everything.

When Should You Use This Audit Approach?

This isn't a "nice to have" or "get around to it eventually" thing. Here's when you absolutely need to run this audit:

Right now if:

  • You haven't looked at your GBP in more than 3 months
  • You're not showing up in local search results where you used to
  • Your business information has changed (moved, new phone, expanded services)
  • You're getting fewer calls/visits from Google than you used to
  • You just took over managing the profile from someone else
  • You've never done a structured audit before

Quarterly maintenance: Even if everything's working great, I recommend running through these 10 elements every 3 months. Things drift. Google adds features. Your business evolves. Quarterly check-ins keep everything aligned.

After major changes: Renovated your space? New product line? Expanded hours? Changed your name? Any significant business change means it's audit time.

Before campaigns: Planning to invest in local ads or marketing? Audit first. There's no point driving traffic to an outdated or incomplete profile.

When competitors are outranking you: If a competitor who shouldn't be beating you is showing up higher in local results, audit both profiles. I guarantee they're doing one or more of these 10 things better than you.

I learned this lesson with a retail client. They were frustrated that a newer competitor was outranking them. When I audited both profiles, the competitor had 30 recent photos, complete service listings, and responded to every review. My client had 5 old photos, vague services, and hadn't touched reviews in months. Mystery solved.

What Mistakes Should You Avoid?

I've seen (and made) a lot of mistakes with GBP audits. Here are the big ones to avoid:

Mistake 1: Checking Everything Once and Calling It Done

GBP isn't a "set it and forget it" platform. I've watched businesses do a perfect audit, fix everything, and then ignore their profile for a year. By the time they check back, half the information is outdated and their rankings have tanked.

Fix: Schedule recurring reminders. Put "GBP check" on your calendar every month, even if it's just a 15-minute review.

Mistake 2: Keyword Stuffing Your Business Name

I get it. You want to rank for "best pizza in Chicago." But adding that to your business name ("Joe's Pizza - Best Pizza in Chicago") violates Google's guidelines and can get your profile suspended.

Fix: Keep your business name as it appears on your storefront and legal documents. Use keywords naturally in your description and services instead.

Mistake 3: Ignoring Negative Reviews

This one hurts to watch. A business gets a bad review, panics, and... does nothing. Or argues with the customer publicly. Both are terrible strategies.

Fix: Respond to every negative review professionally within 48 hours. Acknowledge the issue, apologize if appropriate, and offer to make it right offline. This shows future customers you care about service.

Mistake 4: Using Low-Quality or Outdated Photos

Stock photos, blurry images, or photos from 5 years ago aren't doing you any favors. Customers notice. Google notices.

Fix: Take new photos with your smartphone every few months. Natural lighting, clear focus, and current representation of your business are all you need.

Mistake 5: Selecting Inaccurate Categories or Attributes

Choosing "Restaurant" when you're really a "Coffee Shop," or claiming "wheelchair accessible" when you have stairs... these aren't just SEO mistakes. They create bad customer experiences and can expose you to complaints.

Fix: Be honest. Select only categories and attributes that accurately represent your business right now.

Mistake 6: Inconsistent NAP Across Platforms

I can't stress this enough because I see it constantly. Your address is "123 Main St" on GBP but "123 Main Street" on your website and "123 Main St, Suite A" on Yelp.

Fix: Create a master document with your exact NAP as it should appear everywhere. Then audit every platform and make them match exactly.

Mistake 7: Not Monitoring Performance Data

You're making changes blind if you're not checking what's working. I've seen businesses invest hours into updates without ever looking at whether those updates improved anything.

Fix: Check your GBP Performance tab monthly. Track trends. Connect changes to results.

Mistake 8: Trying to Game the System

Fake reviews, keyword-stuffed names, misleading categories... Google's gotten really good at detecting this stuff. The short-term gain isn't worth the long-term risk.

Fix: Play by the rules. They're not that restrictive, and following them actually works better long-term.

The Tools That Actually Help

You don't need a bunch of fancy software to do this audit. But a few tools make life easier:

For basic audits:

  • Google Business Profile dashboard (free, built-in)
  • Google Rich Results Test (for schema verification)
  • Your smartphone camera (for photos)

For deeper insights:

  • GMBMantra (automates review responses, tracks performance, suggests optimizations)
  • GMB Everywhere (Chrome extension for quick data overlays)
  • Whitespark (for citation tracking and local SEO)

For review management:

  • Native GBP notifications
  • GMBMantra's AI-powered review response tool

Honestly? You can do 90% of this with just the free GBP dashboard and some discipline. The paid tools save time and provide deeper analytics, but they're not required to get results.

I ran audits for years with nothing but a spreadsheet and the native dashboard. Worked fine. Now I use GMBMantra because it saves me hours on review responses and performance tracking, but that's a convenience choice.

Quick Wins You Can Implement Today

Don't want to do a full audit right now? I get it. Here are the fastest fixes that deliver immediate impact:

  • Update your business hours (2 minutes): Make sure they're current, especially if you have holiday hours coming up.
  • Add 3 new photos (15 minutes): Exterior, interior, and product/service shots. Take them on your phone right now.
  • Respond to your 3 most recent reviews (10 minutes): Thank positive reviewers. Address concerns in negative ones.
  • Fill out your services section (20 minutes): List your top 5-10 services with short descriptions.
  • Check your primary category (2 minutes): Make sure it's the most specific match for what you do.
  • Add missing attributes (5 minutes): Scan the list and select anything applicable you haven't claimed.

Total time: About an hour. These six quick fixes will improve your profile noticeably.

Wrapping This Up: What Actually Matters

Look, I've audited hundreds of Google Business Profiles at this point. I've seen businesses obsess over tiny details while missing glaring problems. I've watched competitors with worse products outrank better businesses just because they managed these 10 fundamentals better.

Here's what I want you to take away:

GBP success isn't complicated. It's not about secret hacks or gaming the algorithm. It's about consistently doing these 10 things well: keeping your NAP accurate, choosing the right categories, writing a real description, maintaining fresh photos, listing your services, selecting accurate attributes, managing reviews, implementing schema, monitoring performance, and keeping everything complete.

That's it. That's the list.

You don't need to be perfect. You just need to be better than your competitors at these basics. And honestly? Most of them aren't doing these basics well.

It's ongoing, not one-time. The businesses that win local search treat their GBP like a living thing that needs regular attention, not a form they filled out once in 2019.

If you're feeling overwhelmed, start with the quick wins I mentioned. Get those done this week. Then schedule an hour to work through the full 10-element audit. Then set a recurring calendar reminder to maintain it.

And if managing all this consistently sounds like more than you can handle—especially the review responses and performance tracking—that's where tools like GMBMantra can help. Their AI handles the repetitive stuff (review responses, performance monitoring, optimization suggestions) so you can focus on running your actual business. They offer a free trial if you want to see how automation can simplify this whole process.

But whether you do it manually or use tools, just do it. Your competitors are either ignoring their GBP entirely or trying to optimize 47 different things poorly. You can beat both groups by doing these 10 things well.

Now go audit your profile. I'll wait here.

---

Frequently Asked Questions

How long does a complete GBP audit take? A thorough audit of these 10 core elements takes 60-90 minutes for a single location. Multi-location businesses need about 30-45 minutes per additional location after the first, since you'll develop a system.

Can I do this audit myself or do I need to hire someone? You can absolutely do this yourself. The steps aren't technically complicated—they just require attention to detail and consistency. Hire help only if you don't have the time or if schema markup implementation feels too technical.

How often should I audit my Google Business Profile? Run a full audit quarterly (every 3 months) and do quick monthly check-ins for reviews, photos, and basic information accuracy. Audit immediately after any major business changes like moves or service expansions.

What's the biggest mistake businesses make with GBP audits? Treating it as a one-time task. They audit, fix everything, and then ignore the profile for a year. GBP requires ongoing maintenance—reviews need responses, photos need updating, and information needs to stay current.

Do I really need schema markup on my website? It's not absolutely required, but it significantly helps Google verify your business information is consistent between your website and GBP. Think of it as a strong recommendation rather than optional.

How do I know if my audit is actually improving results? Check your GBP Performance tab monthly. Track metrics like search impressions, website clicks, direction requests, and phone calls. Compare month-over-month and quarter-over-quarter to see trends.

What if my competitors are outranking me even after I fix everything? These 10 elements are foundational, but in highly competitive markets you might need additional strategies like building more reviews, creating more content, or improving your overall online presence. However, fix these basics first—you'd be surprised how often that's enough.

Can I use the same photos across multiple locations? No. Each location should have unique photos that represent that specific location. Generic or duplicated photos across multiple profiles can hurt your credibility and rankings.

Should I respond to every review, even short positive ones? Yes. Even a simple "Thanks for the kind words, Sarah! We appreciate your business" shows you're engaged and care about customer feedback. It takes 30 seconds and builds goodwill.

What happens if I have incorrect information I can't change? If you can't edit something directly (sometimes Google locks fields), use the "Suggest an edit" feature or contact Google Business Profile support. For persistent issues, document the correct information everywhere else online to establish consistency.